This post may contain affiliate links.

Playing by Heart
by Anne Mateer - So just over a week ago, I was casually browsing the Large Type section at my library (I know!), mostly looking for ideas. Since I almost always use reading glasses now, I've also found that it's handy to have an LT book around for those times when I want to read for a little bit without having to hunt down the glasses. This cover and title caught my eye, even though I had never heard of the author before, and I took a chance on it.
This story takes place during the Great War, and the narrative switches back and forth between the two main characters in alternating chapters. Lula is the youngest in a large family, and when the story opens she is teaching college mathematics while pursuing a graduate degree. She receives the news from home that her sister's husband has died unexpectedly. While at home, the older siblings assume that she will be the one to care for the widowed sister and her family, since Fruity Lu (as they nicknamed her) has no husband or family of her own, and they consider her pursuit of higher education to be pointless. Lula puts all her ambitions on hold, figuratively grits her teeth, and seeks a job at the local high school so she can help her sister. She takes the only teaching job the school has available - teaching music, which she doesn't consider her strength; and also finds herself coaching the girls' basketball team, despite knowing nothing at all about the sport.
The male counterpart - and of course, the love interest - is Chet. He is the mathematics teacher and boy's basketball coach; and is caring for his widowed mother, who remains bitter over her late husband's shameful death; and Chet sees that she prefers his brother Clay and views him as courageous because he has enlisted while Chet has not. Chet is also doing the right thing by staying home with his mother, even though he thinks that he is viewed as a coward for doing so.
It did take me awhile to get invested in the story, possibly because the writing style did not resonate with me; but I really did want to like the book right from the start. I did like that the narration alternated chapter by chapter, and with a chapter heading making it clear whether Chet or Lula was 'speaking'. I think that was done well, so that I always knew whose viewpoint I was reading. I thought it was an interesting storyline, even though it took me several chapters before it or the characters really grabbed me. I kept thinking I could figure out how Lula and Chet would finally overcome obstacles to their obvious attraction to each other, but some new misunderstanding or problem would arise and I'd be guessing again.
Overall, an enjoyable read, with an ending that wasn't as predictable as I'd expected.













